ADM Reaches Settlement With SEC Over Intersegment Sales Investigation
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission looked into ADM and found that the company had to pay $40 million to settle the case. The settlement ends claims about how the company’s Nutrition business sells products between its different parts. As part of the deal, ADM did not say whether or not they did anything wrong.
The company also said that the U.S. Department of Justice ended its own investigation without taking any further action. This result takes away any possible criminal liability for the same actions. The resolution lets ADM move on from a time when it was under more regulatory scrutiny.
Source: Business Wire/Website
SEC Probe Focused on Nutrition Unit Performance Inflation
Regulators looked into whether ADM made its Nutrition business unit’s reported performance look better than it really was. The investigation was mostly about transactions between segments that were used when the unit didn’t meet its operating profit goals. Authorities looked into whether changes made to the financial results shown to investors were misleading.
The SEC said that some accounting methods moved profits from other parts of the business into Nutrition. These transfers are said to have made it look like growth was steady. Investigators thought the behavior was misleading instead of just normal changes to internal prices.
Former Executives Cited for Directing Improper Adjustments
The SEC said that former chief financial officers Vikram Luthar and Ray G. Young, as well as former Nutrition head Vince Macciocchi, did things that were against the law. According to the complaint, these executives told or agreed to make targeted changes. The goal was supposedly to reach the projected growth targets for operating profit.
The changes included price changes and rebates that were not available to third-party customers. Regulators said the changes were meant to reach certain dollar amounts. People called these kinds of actions one-sided transfers instead of market-based transactions.
Recommended Article: Sacramento Bee Strengthens Business Coverage With New Hires
Adjustments Allegedly Masked Shortfalls Across Multiple Years
The SEC said that there were improper changes made between 2019 and 2022. People said that Luthar and Macciocchi had planned changes for 2021 and 2022. People blamed Young for carelessly approving similar actions in the past.
These steps were said to have hidden problems when Nutrition didn’t do well. Regulators said that the changes made financial reporting less accurate. The behavior was seen as not following antifraud and internal control rules.
Cooperation and Remediation Influenced Settlement Terms
The SEC said that when it agreed to the settlement, it took into account ADM’s cooperation. The business did an internal investigation and willingly told regulators what they found. It also gave more analysis from an outside accounting expert.
After the review, ADM took a lot of important steps to fix the problems. These included new rules for how to keep track of transactions between different parts of the company. Policies, procedures, and control testing were all made stronger to stop it from happening again.
Financial Penalties Extend Beyond Corporate Settlement
In addition to the $40 million civil fine that ADM had to pay, individual executives also had to pay fines. Macciocchi and Young agreed to pay back prejudgment interest and civil penalties. The amounts were based on their jobs and how long they were in charge.
The SEC also accused Luthar of fraud and other related crimes. He left ADM in 2024 and refused to settle. His lawyer said that he denies all of the accusations and plans to fight them in court.
Leadership Frames Settlement as Turning Point for Governance
Juan Luciano, the chair and CEO of ADM, said the company is happy to move on from the issue. He stressed the importance of using the experience to improve internal controls. Integrity and openness were named as ongoing priorities.
The problems go back to ADM’s $3 billion purchase of Wild Flavors GmbH in 2014. Later, that business joined the Nutrition group. The settlement ends a chapter related to that growth and strengthens reforms in governance.
